Notq Arrives at the Clinic: How Druze Therapists Deal with the Cultural Phenomenon of Remembering and Talking about Previous Incarnation Among the Druze in Israel
Corresponding Author
Maha Natoor
Faculty of Education, University of Haifa, Haifa, Israel
Email: [email protected]
Search for more papers by this authorAvihu Shoshana
Faculty of Education, University of Haifa, Haifa, Israel
Search for more papers by this authorCorresponding Author
Maha Natoor
Faculty of Education, University of Haifa, Haifa, Israel
Email: [email protected]
Search for more papers by this authorAvihu Shoshana
Faculty of Education, University of Haifa, Haifa, Israel
Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
This article deals with the cultural idiom Notq—the remembering and talking about a previous incarnation among the Druze. The study focuses on the interface between the dominant Western psychological perspective and the Druze ethnopsychology. Sixteen Druze therapists including social workers and psychologists were interviewed about the Notq and how it arises in the clinic. The research shows that while the therapists understand and respect Notq, they mostly suspend it and only some work with it. The findings reveal that the Druze therapists are confronted with a complex conflict: they have no internal-cultural legitimacy to reject Notq, and they have no external-professional basis for accepting it. This study, in using the example of the Notq, illustrates important issues that are addressed by transcultural psychologists and psychological anthropologists; cultural idioms; minority therapists; the dominance of Western psychological knowledge; and the interface between psychology and religion.
References Cited
- Abramowitz, Sharon Alane. 2010. “Trauma and Humanitarian Translation in Liberia: The Tale of Open Mole.” Culture, Medicine, and Psychiatry 34 (2): 353–79.
- Al-Krenawi, Alean, and John R. Graham. 2011. “Mental Health Help-Seeking Among Arab University Students in Israel, Differentiated by Religion.” Mental Health, Religion & Culture 14 (2): 157–67.
10.1080/13674670903454229 Google Scholar
- Araidi, Nadia. 2015. Ways in which the Ministry of Education deals with Druze children who experience the phenomenon of “El-nuteq” – memories of a previous incarnation. Oranim College, Israel: Unpublished master's thesis. [Hebrew].
- Bennett, Anne. 2006. “Reincarnation, Sect Unity, and Identity Among the Druze.” Ethnology 45 (2): 87–104.
- Bienenfeld, David, and Joel Yager. 2007. “Issues of Spirituality and Religion in Psychotherapy Supervision.” Israel Journal of Psychiatry and Related Sciences 44 (3): 178–86.
- Brown, Ottilia, Diane Elkonin, and Samantha Naicker. 2013. “The use of Religion and Spirituality in Psychotherapy: Enablers and Barriers.” Journal of Religion and Health 52 (4): 1131–46.
- Cabral, Raquel R., and Timothy B. Smith. 2011. “Racial/ethnic Matching of Clients and Therapists in Mental Health Services: A meta-Analytic Review of Preferences, Perceptions, and Outcomes.” Journal of Counseling Psychology 58 (4): 537–54.
- Cardeña, Etzel, and Yvonne Schaffler. 2018. “’He who has the Spirits Must Work a lot’: A Psycho-Anthropological Account of Spirit Possession in the Dominican Republic.” Ethos 46 (4): 457–76.
- Christopherson, Beth, and Julie Beischel. 2018. “Assessing afterlife beliefs in psychotherapy.” Threshold: Journal of Interdisciplinary Consciousness Studies 2 (1): 50–74.
- Daie, Netzer, Eliezer Witztum, Mordechai Mark, and Stanley Rabinowitz. 1992. “The Belief in the Transmigration of Souls: Psychotherapy of a Druze Patient with Severe Anxiety Reaction.” Psychology and Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice 65 (2): 119–30.
- Dana, Nissim. 1998. The Druze. Ramat-Gan: Bar-Ilan University. [Hebrew].
- Dana, Nissim. 2009. “Druze Identity and Religion: Tradition and Apostasy.” Shnaton, 9. Published in English and retrieved from www.shaanan.ac.il/shnaton/15/4.pdf.
- Deegan, James G. 1995. “The Friendly Cultural Stranger as self-Critical Reflexive narrator.” Anthropology & Education Quarterly 26 (3): 349–57.
- Dwairy, Marwan. 2006. “The Psychosocial Function of Reincarnation Among Druze in Israel.” Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry 30 (1): 29–53.
- Faraj, Raja. 2006. Reincarnation – an in-depth analysis of the topic of reincarnation in various cultures and religions focusing on case studies from the Druze community. Tarshiha, Israel: Library and Computers. [Hebrew].
- Goode-Cross, David T., and Karen Ann Grim. 2016. ““An Unspoken level of Comfort” Black Therapists’ Experiences Working with Black Clients.” Journal of Black Psychology 42 (1): 29–53.
- Hage, Sally. 2006. “A Closer Look at the Role of Spirituality in Psychology Training Programs.” Professional Psychology: Research and Practice 37 (3): 303–10.
- Halabi, Rabah. 2013. “Invention of a Nation: The Druze in Israel.” Journal of Asian and African Studies 49 (3): 267–81.
- Halabi, Rabah, and Gabriel Horenczyk. 2019. “Reincarnation Beliefs Among Israeli Druze and the Construction of a Hard-Primordial Identity.” Death Studies 44 (6): 347–56.
- Haraldsson, Erlendur. 2003. “Children who Speak of Past-life Experiences: is there a Psychological Explanation?” Psychology and Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice 76 (1): 55–67.
- Hasan, Yusef. 2011. Druze between Geography and Society: A Look from Inside. Haifa: Reuven Chaikin Chair in Geostrategy.
- Iancu Iulian, Baruch Spivak, Roberto Mester, and Abraham Weizman. 1998. “Belief in Transmigration of the Soul and Psychopathology in Israeli Druze.” Psychopathology 31 (1): 52–58.
- Ito, Karen L., and Gloria G. Maramba. 2002. “Therapeutic Beliefs of Asian American Therapists: Views from an Ethnic-Specific Clinic.” Transcultural Psychiatry 39 (1): 33–73.
10.1177/136346150203900102 Google Scholar
- Kidron, Carol A., and Laurence J. Kirmayer. 2018. “Global Mental health and Idioms of Distress: the Paradox of Culture-Sensitive Pathologization of Distress in Cambodia.” Culture, Medicine, and Psychiatry 43 (2): 211–35.
- Kidron, Carol A., Dan M. Kotliar, and Laurence J. Kirmayer. 2019. “Transmitted Trauma as Badge of honor: Phenomenological Accounts of Holocaust Descendant Resilient Vulnerability.” Social Science & Medicine 239 (C): 1–9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.socscimed.2019.112524
- Kirmayer, Laurence J., and Dinesh Bhugra. 2009. “ Culture and Mental Illness: Social Context and Explanatory Models.” in Psychiatric Diagnosis: Patterns and Prospects, eds I. M. Salloum and J. E. Mezzich (New York, NY: John Wiley & Sons): 29–37.
10.1002/9780470743485.ch3 Google Scholar
- Kirmayer, Laurence J., Cécile Rousseau, G. Eric Jarvis, and Jaswant Guzder. 2015. “ The Cultural Context of Clinical Assessment.” In A. Tasman, M. Maj, M.B. First, J. Kay & J. Lieberman (Eds.), Psychiatry ( 4th edition): 54–66. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
- Kirmayer, Laurence J., Ana Gomez-Carrillo, and Samuel Veissiere. 2017. “Culture and Depression in Global Mental Health: An Ecosocial Approach to the Phenomenology of Psychiatric Disorders.” Social Science & Medicine 100 (183): 163–68.
- Kleinman, Arthur. 1978. “Concepts and a Model for the Comparison of Medical Systems as Cultural Systems.” Social Science & Medicine 12 (2B): 85–93.
- Kozuki, Yoriko, and Michael G. Kennedy. 2004. “Cultural Incommensurability in Psychodynamic Psychotherapy in Western and Japanese Traditions.” Journal of Nursing Scholarship 36 (1): 30–38.
- Lasater, Molly E., Madeleine Beebe, Nicole E. Warren, Fatoumata Souko, Mariam Keita, Sarah M. Murray, Judith K. Bass, Pamela J. Surkan, and Peter J. Winch. 2018. “Dusukasi-the Heart that Cries: An Idiom of Mental Distress Among Perinatal Women In rural Mali.” Culture, Medicine, and Psychiatry 42 (4): 930–45.
- Littlewood, Roland. 2001. “Social Institutions and Psychological Explanations: Druze Reincarnation as a Therapeutic Resource.” British Journal of Medical Psychology 74 (2): 213–22.
- Manor-Binyamini, Iris, and Avihu Shoshana. 2018. Listening to Bedouin Mothers of Children with Autism. Culture, Medicine, and Psychiatry 2 (42): 401–18.
- Moorehead, Virgil D., Joseph P. Gone, and Damia December. 2015. “A Gathering of Native American Healers: Exploring the Interface of Indigenous Tradition and Professional Practice.” American Journal of Community Psychology 56 (3-4): 383–94.
- Morrow, Susan L. 2005. “Quality and Trustworthiness in Qualitative Research in Counseling Psychology.” Journal of counseling psychology 52 (2): 250–60.
- Natour, Samih, and Akram Hasson. 2001. The Druze. Daliat El Carmel- Israel: Asia Publications.
- Nichter, Mark. 2010. “Idioms of Distress Revisited.” Culture, Medicine, and Psychiatry 34 (2): 401–16.
- Nigst, Lorenz. 2017. “Being one and two and Druze: Problems of Belonging in the Remembrance of Previous lives.” International forum on Audio-Visual research 8: 56–81. retrieved from https://www.taqammus.at/wp/wp-content/uploads/040_82665_JPA8_nigst_056-081.pdf
- Noy, Chaim. (2008). “Sampling Knowledge: The Hermeneutics of Snowball Sampling in Qualitative Research.” International Journal of Social Research Methodology 11(4): 327–44.
- Pargament, Kenneth I., and Stephen M. Saunders. 2007. “Introduction to the Special Issue on Spirituality and Psychotherapy.” Journal of Clinical Psychology 63 (10): 903–07.
- Peres, Julio FP. 2012. “Should Psychotherapy Consider Reincarnation?” The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 200 (2): 174–79.
- Reeves, Allison, and Suzanne L. Stewart. 2015. “Exploring the Integration of Indigenous Healing and Western Psychotherapy for Sexual Trauma Survivors who use Mental Health Services at Anishnawbe Health Toronto.” Canadian Journal of Counselling and Psychotherapy 49 (1): 57–78.
- Segall, Marshall H., Walter J. Lonner, and John W. Berry. 1998. “Cross-Cultural Psychology as a Scholarly Discipline: On the Flowering of Culture in Behavioral Research.” American Psychologist 53 (10): 1101–10.
- Somer, Eli, Carmit Klein-Sela, and Keren Or-Chen. 2011. “Beliefs in Reincarnation and the Power of fate and their Association with Emotional Outcomes Among Bereaved Parents of Fallen Soldiers.” Journal of Loss and Trauma 16 (5): 459–75.
- Spivak Baruch, Iulian Iancu, Netzer Daie, and Abraham Weizman. 1995. “The Belief in the Transmigration of Souls as a Presenting Symptom of Generalized Anxiety Disorder in a Military Setting.” Psychopathology 28 (3): 158–60.
- Stevenson, Ian. 1990. “Phobias in Children who Claim to Remember Previous Lives.” Journal of Scientific Exploration 4 (2): 243–54.
- Stevenson, Ian. 2000. “The Phenomenon of Claimed Memories of Previous Lives: Possible Interpretations and Importance.” Medical Hypotheses 54 (4): 652–59.
- Strauss, Anselm, and Juliet Corbin. 1998. Basics of qualitative research techniques. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage publications.
- Weng, Suzie., and Lisa Gray. 2017. “Advancement in Social work Education: Fostering a Supportive Environment for Students of Non-Dominant Racial and Ethnic Backgrounds.” Social Work Education 36 (6): 662–77.
- Wilk, Katarzyna. 2014. “Using a Pluralistic Approach in Counselling Psychology and Psychotherapy Practice with Diverse Clients: Explorations into Cultural and Religious Responsiveness Within a Western Paradigm.” Counselling Psychology Review 29 (1): 16–28.
- Zher-Aldien, Naief. 2008. Life after death: truth or imagination? Lebanon: Riyadh al-Reiss. [Arabic].