Predictors of Land Privatization: Cross-Cultural Tests of Defendability and Resource Stress Theory
Corresponding Author
Carol R. Ember
Human Relations Area Files, Inc., New Haven, Connecticut, 06511 USA
email: [email protected]
Search for more papers by this authorTeferi Abate Adem
Human Relations Area Files, Inc., New Haven, Connecticut, 06511 USA
Search for more papers by this authorTahlisa Brougham
NYU School of Law, New York, New York, 10012 USA
Search for more papers by this authorEmily Pitek
George Washington University, Washington, DC, 20052 USA
Search for more papers by this authorCorresponding Author
Carol R. Ember
Human Relations Area Files, Inc., New Haven, Connecticut, 06511 USA
email: [email protected]
Search for more papers by this authorTeferi Abate Adem
Human Relations Area Files, Inc., New Haven, Connecticut, 06511 USA
Search for more papers by this authorTahlisa Brougham
NYU School of Law, New York, New York, 10012 USA
Search for more papers by this authorEmily Pitek
George Washington University, Washington, DC, 20052 USA
Search for more papers by this authorABSTRACT
enWe have known for some time that complex societies are more likely to have land tenure systems based on private rights and less likely to have communal ownership. Less understood is why. More specifically, what are the mechanisms to explain why complex societies have more private property? What are the adaptive advantages of one system rather than the other? Conceptualizing and coding land tenure systems as a “bundle of rights,” this worldwide cross-cultural study suggests that Acheson's (2015) economic defendability theory in conjunction with some environmental stressors, such as drought, may help us understand cross-cultural variation in land tenure systems. Our results have evolutionary implications. They suggest that if property rights were claimed, communal property systems would have been the default system for any society having substantial degrees of hunting, gathering, or herdable animals. Agriculture by itself is not a strong predictor of private land rights, although irrigation agriculture is. [land tenure systems, defendability, resource stress, cross-cultural]
RESUMEN
frHemos sabido por algún tiempo que las sociedades complejas tienen más probabilidad de tener sistemas de tenencia de la tierra basados en derechos de propiedad privada y menos probabilidad de tener propiedad comunal. Menos entendido es el por qué. Más específicamente, ¿cuáles son los mecanismos para explicar por qué las sociedades complejas tienen más propiedades privadas? ¿Cuáles son las ventajas adaptativas de un sistema en lugar del otro? Al conceptualizar y codificar los sistemas de tenencia de la tierra como un “conjunto de derechos,” este estudio transcultural sugiere que la teoría de la defendibilidad económica de Acheson (2015) junto con algunos factores que causan estrés ambiental, como la sequía, pueden ayudar a entender la variación transcultural en sistemas de tenencia de la tierra. Nuestros resultados tienen implicaciones evolucionarias. Ellos sugieren que, si los derechos de propiedad fueron reclamados, los sistemas de propiedad comunal podrían haber sido el sistema por defecto para cualquier sociedad teniendo grados sustanciales de caza, recolección o animales de pastoreo. La agricultura por sí misma no es un predictor fuerte de los derechos de propiedad privada de la tierra, aunque la agricultura con irrigación lo es. [sistemas de tenencia de la tierra, defendibilidad, estrés en los recursos, transcultural]
Supporting Information
Filename | Description |
---|---|
aman13484-sup-0001-SuppMat.docx84.3 KB | Supplemental Code S1 |
Please note: The publisher is not responsible for the content or functionality of any supporting information supplied by the authors. Any queries (other than missing content) should be directed to the corresponding author for the article.
REFERENCES CITED
- Acheson, James M. 2015. “Private Land and Common Oceans Analysis of the Development of Property Regimes.” Current Anthropology 56 (1): 28–55.
- Adger, W. Neil. 2000. “Social and Ecological Resilience: Are They Related?” Progress in Human Geography 24 (3): 347–64.
- Baker, Matthew J. 2003. “An Equilibrium Conflict Model of Land Tenure in Hunter-Gatherer Societies.” Journal of Political Economy 111 (1): 124–73.
- Behrendt, S. 2014. “ lm. beta: Add Standardized Regression Coefficients to lm-Objects.” R package version 1.5-1.
- Berry, Sara. 1993. No Condition Is Permanent: The Social Dynamics of Agrarian Change in Sub-Saharan Africa. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
- Berry, Sara. 2002. “Debating the Land Question in Africa.” Comparative Studies in Society and History 44 (4): 638–68.
- Blanton, Richard E. 2016. How Humans Cooperate: Confronting the Challenges of Collective Action. Boulder: University Press of Colorado.
10.5876/9781607325147 Google Scholar
- Boehm, Christopher. 2012. Moral Origins: The Evolution of Virtue, Altruism, and Shame. New York: Basic Books.
- Bowles, Samuel, and Herbert Gintis. 2013. A Cooperative Species: Human Reciprocity and Its Evolution. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
- Bromley, Daniel W., David Feeny, Margaret A. McKean, Pauline Peters, Jere L. Gilles, Ronald J. Oakerson, C. Ford Runge, and James T. Thomson. 1992. Making the Commons Work: Theory, Practice and Policy. San Francisco, IC Press
- Bruce, John W. 1986. “ Land Tenure Issues in Project Design and Strategies for Agricultural Development in Sub-Saharan Africa.” Land Tenure Center, University of Wisconsin–Madison.
- Bruce, John W., and S. E. Migot-Adholia. 1994. Searching for Land Tenure Security in Africa. Dubuque: Kendall/Hunt Publishing Company.
- Cashdan, Elizabeth, Alan Barnard, M. C. Bicchieri, Charles A. Bishop, Valda Blundell, Jeffrey Ehrenreich, Mathias Guenther, et al. 1983. “Territoriality among Human Foragers: Ecological Models and an Application to Four Bushman Groups.” Current Anthropology 24 (1): 47–66.
- Chabot-Hanowell, Benjamin, and Eric Alden Smith. 2012. “5 Territorial and Nonterritorial Routes to Power: Reconciling Evolutionary Ecological, Social Agency, and Historicist Approaches.” Archeological Papers of the American Anthropological Association 22 (1): 72–86.
10.1111/apaa.12004 Google Scholar
- Core Writing Team, Rajendra K. Pachauri, and L. A. Meyer. 2014. “ IPCC, 2014: Climate Change 2014: Synthesis Report. Contribution of Working Groups I.” II and III to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Geneva: IPCC.
- Cronk, Lee, and Beth L. Leech. 2013. Meeting at Grand Central: Understanding the Social and Evolutionary Roots of Cooperation. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
10.1515/9781400845484 Google Scholar
- Dirks, Robert. 1993. “Starvation and Famine: Cross-Cultural Codes and Some Hypothesis Tests.” Cross-Cultural Research 27 (1–2): 28–69.
10.1177/106939719302700103 Google Scholar
- Dirks, Robert. 2004. “ Hunger and Famine.” In Research Frontiers in Anthropology: New Directions in Anthropology, edited by Carol R. Ember and Melvin Ember, 2–18. Upper Saddle River: Prentice-Hall
- Divale, William T. 2004. “Codebook of Variables for the Standard Cross-Cultural Sample.” World Cultures 14 (2): 1–347.
- Divale, William T., and Albert Seda. 2000. “Cross-Cultural Codes of Modernization.” World Cultures 11 (2): 152–70.
- Dyson-Hudson, Rada, and Eric Alden Smith. 1978. “Human Territoriality: An Ecological Reassessment.” American Anthropologist 80 (1): 21–41.
- Editors of Ethnology. 1962ff. “Ethnographic Atlas.” Ethnology.
- Ekstrøm, C. T. 2019. “ MESS: Miscellaneous Esoteric Statistical Scripts. R package version 0.5.6.” https://github.com/ekstroem/MESS.
- Ember, Carol R. 2007. “Using the HRAF Collection of Ethnography in Conjunction with the Standard Cross-Cultural Sample and the Ethnographic Atlas.” Cross-Cultural Research 41 (4): 396–427.
- Ember, Carol R., and Melvin Ember. 1992a. “Resource Unpredictability, Mistrust, and War: A Cross-Cultural Study.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 36: 242–62.
- Ember, Carol R., and Melvin Ember. 1992b. “Warfare, Aggression, and Resource Problems: Cross-Cultural Codes.” Cross-Cultural Research 26: 169–226.
10.1177/106939719202600108 Google Scholar
- Ember, Carol R., and Melvin Ember. 2009. Cross-Cultural Research Methods. Second edition. Lanham: AltaMira Press.
- Ember, Carol R., Melvin Ember, and Burton Pasternak. 1974. “On the Development of Unilineal Descent.” Journal of Anthropological Research 30 (2): 69–94.
- Ember, Carol R., Ian Skoggard, Erik J. Ringen, and Megan Farrer. 2018. “Our Better Nature: Does Resource Stress Predict Beyond-Household Sharing?” Evolution and Human Behavior 39 (4): 380–91. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.evolhumbehav.2018.03.001.
- Engels, Friedrich, and Tristram Hunt. (1884) 2010. The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State. London: Penguin Books.
- Feder, Gershon, and Raymond Noronha. 1987. “Land Rights Systems and Agricultural Development in Sub-Saharan Africa.” The World Bank Research Observer 2 (2): 143–69.
10.1093/wbro/2.2.143 Google Scholar
- Felzer, B. S., C. R. Ember, R. Cheng, and M. Jiang. 2020. “The Relationships of Extreme Precipitation and Temperature Events with Ethnographic Reports of Droughts and Floods in Nonindustrial Societies” Weather, Climate, and Society 12 (1): 135–48.
- Folke, Carl. 2006. “Resilience: The Emergence of a Perspective for Social–Ecological Systems Analyses.” Global Environmental Change 16 (3): 253–67.
- Folke, Carl, S. Carpenter, B. Walker, M. Scheffer, T. Chapin, and J. Rockström. 2010. “Resilience Thinking: Integrating Resilience, Adaptability and Transformability.” Ecology and Society 15 (4). http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol15/iss4/art20/.
- Fox, J., and Sanford Weisberg. 2019. An {R} Companion to Applied Regression. Third edition. Los Angeles: SAGE. https://socialsciences.mcmaster.ca/jfox/Books/Companion/.
- Fratkin, Elliot, and Eric Abella Roth. 2006. As Pastoralists Settle: Social, Health, and Economic Consequences of the Pastoral Sedentarization in Marsabit District, Kenya. Volume 1. New York: Kluwer Academic.
- Geertz, Clifford. 1980. “ Organization of the Balinese Subak.” In Irrigation and Agricultural Development in Asia: Perspectives from the Social Sciences, edited by E. Waltern Coward, 70–90. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
- Hardin, Garrett. 1968. “The Tragedy of the Commons.” Science 162 (3859): 1243–48.
- Hobhouse, L. T., Gerald Clair William Camden Wheeler, and Morris Ginsberg. 1915. The Material Culture and Social Institutions of the Simpler Peoples; An Essay in Correlation, London School of Economics and Political Science (University of London) Series of Studies in Economics and Political Science No 3 of the Monographs on Sociology. London: Chapman & Hall, ltd.
- Jaeggi, Adrian V., Klaree J. Boose, Frances J. White, and Michael Gurven. 2016. “Obstacles and Catalysts of Cooperation in Humans, Bonobos, and Chimpanzees: Behavioural Reaction Norms Can Help Explain Variation in Sex Roles, Inequality, War Peace.” Behaviour 153 (9–11): 1015–51.
- Labovitz, Sanford. 1970. “The Assignment of Numbers to Rank Order Categories.” American Sociological Review 35: 515–24.
- Lang, Hartmut. 1995. “CONAN—An Electronic Code-Text Data-Base for Cross-Cultural Studies.” World Cultures 9 (2): 1–38.
- Lentz, Carola. 2013. Land, Mobility, and Belonging in West Africa: Natives and Strangers: Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
- Little, Peter D. 2003. “ Rethinking Interdisciplinary Paradigms and the Political Ecology of Pastoralism in East Africa.” In African Savannas: Global Narratives and Local Knowledge of Environmental Changes, edited by T. Bassett and D. Crummey, 161–77. Oxford: James Currey.
- Mazerolle, Marc J. 2019. “ AICcmodavg: Model Selection and Multimodel Inference Based on (Q)AIC(c).” R package version 2.2–2. https://cran.r-project.org/package=AICcmodavg.
- McCabe, J. Terrence. 1987. “Drought and Recovery: Livestock Dynamics among the Ngisonyoka Turkana of Kenya.” Human Ecology 15 (4): 371–89.
- McCabe, J. Terrence. 1990. “Turkana Pastoralism: A Case against the Tragedy of the Commons.” Human Ecology 18 (1): 81–103.
- McPeak, John G., Peter D. Little, and Cheryl R. Doss. 2012. Risk and Change in an African Rural Economy. London: Routledge.
- Murdock, George P., and Caterina Provost. 1973. “Measurement of Cultural Complexity.” Ethnology 12: 379–92.
- Murdock, George P., and Douglas R. White. 1969. “Standard Cross-Cultural Sample.” Ethnology 8: 329–69.
- Nugent, Jeffrey B., and Nicholas Sanchez. 1999. “The Local Variability of Rainfall and Tribal Institutions: The Case of Sudan.” Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 39 (3): 263–91.
- Ostrom, Elinor, Thomas Dietz, Nives Dolšak, Paul C. Stern, Susan Stonich, and Elke U. Weber. 2002. The Drama of the Commons. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.
- Peters, Pauline E. 1994. Dividing the Commons: Politics, Policy, and Culture in Botswana. Charlottesville: University Press of Virginia.
- Pryor, Frederic L. 1977. The Origins of the Economy: A Comparative Study of Distribution in Primitive and Peasant Economies. New York: Academic Press.
- Pryor, Frederic L. 2003. “Economic Systems of Foragers.” Cross-Cultural Research 37 (4): 393–426.
- Pryor, Frederic L. 2005. Economic Systems of Foraging, Agricultural, and Industrial Societies. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
10.1017/CBO9780511754302 Google Scholar
- Pryor, Frederic L. 2011. “ Appendices to Economic Systems of Foraging, Agricultural, and Industrial Societies.” http://www.swarthmore.edu/SocSci/Economics/fpryor1/.
- Ribot, Jesse C, and Nancy Lee Peluso. 2003. “A Theory of Access.” Rural Sociology 68 (2): 153–81.
- Richerson, Peter, Ryan Baldini, Adrian V. Bell, Kathryn Demps, Karl Frost, Vicken Hillis, Sarah Mathew, et al. 2016. “Cultural Group Selection Plays an Essential Role in Explaining Human Cooperation: A Sketch of the Evidence.” Behavioral and Brain Sciences 39:e30.
- Rudmin, Floyd Webster. 1988. “Dominance, Social Control, Ownership: A History and a Cross-Cultural Study of Motivations for Private Property.” Behavior Science Research 22 (1–4): 130–60.
10.1177/106939718802200111 Google Scholar
- Rudmin, Floyd Webster. 1992a. “Cross-Cultural Correlates of the Ownership of Private Property.” Social Science Research 21 (1): 57–83.
- Rudmin, Floyd Webster. 1992b. “Cross-Cultural Correlates of the Ownership of Private Property: A Look from Another Data-Base.” Anthropologica 34: 71–88.
10.2307/25605633 Google Scholar
- Rudmin, Floyd Webster. 1995. “Cross-Cultural Correlates of the Ownership of Private Property: Two Samples of Murdock's Data.” The Journal of Socio-Economics 24 (2): 345–73.
10.1016/1053-5357(95)90025-X Google Scholar
- Rudmin, Floyd Webster. 1996. “Cross-Cultural Correlates of the Ownership of Private Property: Zelman's Gender Data Revisited.” Cross-Cultural Research 30 (2): 115–53.
10.1177/106939719603000201 Google Scholar
- Salzman, Philip. 1971. “Movement and Resource Extraction among Pastoral Nomads: The Case of the Shah Nawazi Baluch.” Anthropological Quarterly 44 (3) 185–97.
- Scoones, Ian, and Carol Kerven. 1993. Range Ecology at Disequilibrium: New Models of Natural Variability and Pastoral Adaptation in African Savannas. London: Overseas Development Institute.
- Scott, James C. 1998. Seeing Like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed. New Haven: Yale University Press.
- Sidky, M. H. 1993. “Irrigation and the Political Evolution of the High-Mountain Kingdom of Hunza1.” Asian Affairs 24 (2): 131–44.
10.1080/714041207 Google Scholar
- Signorell, Andri, Ken Aho, Andreas Alfons, Nanina Anderegg, Tomas Aragon, Antti Arppe, and Adrian Baddeley. 2019. “ DescTools: Tools for Descriptive Statistics. R Package Version 0.99.29.” https://cran.r-project.org/package=DescTools.
- Simmons, Leo W. 1937. “ Statistical Correlations in the Science of Society.” In Studies in the Science of Society, edited by George P. Murdock, 495–517. New Haven: Yale University Press.
- Spier, Leslie. 1928. Havasupai Ethnography. New York: American Museum of Natural History.
- Sumner, William Graham, and Albert Galloway Keller. 1927. The Science of Society. Four volumes. New Haven: Yale University Press.
- Swanson, Guy E. 1964. The Birth of the Gods. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
- Venables, W. N., and B. D. Ripley. 2002. Modern Applied Statistics with S. Fourth edition. New York: Springer
10.1007/978-0-387-21706-2 Google Scholar
- Weisberg, Herbert, Jon A. Krosnick, and Bruce D. Bowen. 1996. An Introduction to Survey Research, Polling, and Data Analysis. Thousand Oaks: SAGE.
- Wickham, Hadley. 2016. ggplot2: Elegant Graphics for Data Analysis. Second edition. New York: Springer-Verlag.
10.1007/978-3-319-24277-4 Google Scholar
- Wrangham, Richard W. 1980. “An Ecological Model of Female-Bonded Primate Groups.” Behaviour 3–4: 262–300.